Skip to content
Call
Text
(618) 382-7383
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Dave Matheny
State Farm® Insurance Agent

Dave Matheny

Dave Matheny Ins Agcy Inc

Office Hours

Address

122 E Main St
P O Box 366
Carmi, IL 62821-0366

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Continue a saved quote Items needed for a quote
File a Claim Send Payment
4.9/5 average rating on Google (150 reviews)
Contact Us
Contact Us
Text Us
Map & Directions
Get ID Card

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Continue a saved quote Items needed for a quote
File a Claim Send Payment

Office Info

Office Hours

Call or text us 24 hours a day!

Address

122 E Main St
P O Box 366
Carmi, IL 62821-0366

Languages

English
Map Image

Dave Matheny State Farm Agency has served the Carmi, Norris City, Grayville, and Mt Carmel area for approximately three decades. We not only help our Illinois Good Neighbors but we are licensed to help Indiana residents as well. My team prides itself on offering friendly and personalized service to customers in the southeastern Illinois area and helping them create coverage to match their Life, Auto, and Home Insurance needs. We will even cover your furry friend with Pet Insurance!

Outside of the office, I am deeply involved in the community. I am a proud member and past board member of the Carmi Kiwanis Club, and I am a Carmi Chamber of Commerce member. I graduated from Millikin University and hold a ChFC and CLU designation. As a long-time area resident of southern Illinois, I am familiar with customers unique needs. I support a variety of local charities and organizations and give back where possible.

If you are ready to get started on creating a personalized insurance plan, I hope you will reach out to my team. We are here to help and looking forward to serving out Good Neighbors!

Happy New Year 2026! Wishing you all a year filled with joy and happiness! Let's make the most out the new year! Our team is always here to help. Call or stop by to learn more!

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Investment Services, Annuities

FINRA’s BrokerCheck View Licenses

Camping safety made simple

A camping trip is a great way to get in touch with nature. Setup your campsite & secure your belongings with the help of these camping safety tips.

Tips for driving on the highway

Here are some helpful tips for how to safely navigate both Interstate and highway driving. This includes day and night trip tips, plus defensive driving measures.

Collision vs. Comprehensive: What’s the difference?

Understand the key differences between collision and comprehensive car insurance. Learn what each covers, when they're needed and how they can work together to help protect your car.

View More Articles

Controller (:15)

Captain :30 (feat. Aidan Hutchinson)

Scooter :15

Riddle Me This

Dave Matheny State Farm is located in Carmi, Illinois, and proudly helps area residents and those in Indiana obtain Pet, Life, and Auto Insurance plans that work for them. We are dedicated to rendering personalized service, and with approximately three decades of experience, I look forward to addressing your coverage needs and concerns. Whether you reside in Crossville, Grayville, or Mill Shoals, my team is here to extend its services. We look forward to getting to know you, Good Neighbors.

People make all the difference when it comes to insurance, and these friendly and talented women will help you every step of the way. Call or click today for a free auto or home insurance quote.

Available Positions
Account Associate - State Farm Agent Team Member

Carmi - IL Full Time

Account Manager - State Farm Agent Team Member

Carmi - IL Full Time

Account Representative - State Farm Agent Team Member

Carmi - IL Full Time

Customer Relations Representative - State Farm Agent Team Member

Carmi - IL Full Time

Customer Service Representative - State Farm Agent Team Member

Carmi - IL Full Time

Receptionist - State Farm Agent Team Member

Carmi - IL Full Time

Learn more about our agency and the career opportunities with us.
Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.